CALLBACK Request Customize Your trip

Myanmar Tour Packages, Holiday, Itinerary Package

The temptation of the West

The early 90’s of the 20th century saw Viet Nam opening itself to the West.
 
Such a movement started once before, timidly it is true, in the 80’s of the last century, when the “white peril” was making itself felt more and more keenly.
 
In the light of the present opening, it may be interesting to examine the state of mind of intellectual elite of that era steeped in Confucianism.
 
We are offered a chance to do so by the recent publication, in Paris, of the Brief Account of a Sea Voyage, by Phan Huy Chu. In 1832-1833, Chu was a Vietnamese envoy to Batavia (now known as Djakarta). This is the first time that this book, long mentioned in scholarly bibliographies, has been made available to the public.
 
At the present juncture, when the countries of Southeast Asia are seeking to restore ancestral ties and find a common history, this document assumes particular significance.
 
Phan Huy Chú, an eminent historian, bom into a family of illustrious scholars, left a Chronology of Dynasties in 49 parts, comprising studies on geography, as well as bibliographies.
 
His voyage to Indonesia (via Singapore) was one of the missions sent out by the Nguyen kings, who attached great importance to the countries of the South Seas for military (buying of weapons), economic, and political reasons.
 
Accompanied by two other officials, Phan Huy Chu was to look into the establishment of Westerners in the region, and their political aims. His account is centered on his voyage from Da Nang to Batavia.
 
Not without a pride, he speaks first of the expansion of the country south' ward, as his boat hugs the coast.
 
In Batavia, as in Singapore, he describes the British and Dutch rule and die servitude of the natives. He is less interested in the latter’s living conditions than in the activities of the white men, although, through his Confucian prism, he considers only the civilisation of the Middle Kingdom to be of value. Both the native populations of the southern islands and the “red-haired” white men he thinks “barbarian.”
 
Rian Huy Chu is impressed by the material and technical feats of the Westerners: wealth, urbanisation, sawmills worked by the force of water, the harnessing of animals, and the development of sea-going vessels, painting, administration and justice.
 
He notes: “It seems that rivalries among the barbarians have not yet ended. It is because then interests are at stake that they continue to be in conflict."
 
On the other hand, the Chinese settlers, on account of their number, wealth, and skills, receive much greater consideration than the native populations.
 
The juxtaposition of Sino-Vietnamese spiritual and moral values to Western ones confers an indisputable superiority to the former.
 
The author condemns the absence of social etiquette: “The practice of right relationship between men of consequence and commoners do not exist. This is because they are not acquainted with the precepts and teachings of the Zhou and Confucius. Thus, though they excel in many talents, they remain barbarians.”
 
This contempt for the material, to the advantage of the spiritual and ethical, was common to intellectuals in the Confucianised countries - China, Japan and Korea - at the time of the first encounter with the West.
 
In Vietnam, apart from a handful of reform-minded scholars, it led the intelligentsia to closure and conservatism - the cause of the loss of the country in the latter part of the 19th century.
 
It is time for us to ponder the lesson of the past and reformulate in Vietnamese terms the concept of “development.” Should openness and the free market drive us, and our young people in particular, to deny our traditional cultural values in exchange for everyday gadgets and ready-made ideological garments imported from the West?
 
Know more about Phan Huy Chu with Holidays in Mui Ne
 
 
Send to your friends Print
Update : 21-07-2017

REVIEWS BY VIDEO

Support Online

Yahoo Support
Skype Support
Hotline : +84 912 264 631
--------------------------------------

Why us ?

1. Local agent - without an intermediate

2. 24/7 availability

3. Quick reply

4. Guaranteed quality service

5. Safety & Security

6. Flexible & Professional staff

Testimonials

Please discover the testimonials of our travelers. They came back from the trip and share their reviews and impressions.

News & Events

Vietnamese in America the second generation
Reading a recently-published memorandum of the congress of former Nam Dinh - Yen Mo Lyceum students, I found the words ...
Balzac's relevance in modern Viet Nam
This publication marks not only the 200th birth anniversary of one of the greatest novelists of all time but also a new ...
The head and the heart of the traditional village
Each village has a communal house (dinh) dedicated to its tutelary god, temples (den, mieu, phu) for the worship of ...